Denied Workers’ Compensation Benefits: What You Should Do Next

Being injured at work is a stressful experience, both physically and emotionally. You’re likely dealing with pain, limited mobility, and the uncertainty of how you’ll manage medical bills and lost wages.  Adding the burden of a denied Workers’ Compensation claim can feel like a gut punch. It can make a difficult situation seem insurmountable.  However, it’s important to remember that you have rights. If you’ve been denied Workers’ Compensation benefits, don’t give up. There are steps you can take to fight for the compensation you deserve. By understanding the reasons for the denial and following the proper procedures, you can increase your chances of a successful outcome.


Understanding Why Your Denied Workers’ Compensation Benefits Claim Was Denied


The first step is to understand why your Denied Workers’ Compensation Benefits claim was rejected. The denial letter you receive should outline the specific reason for the insurer’s decision. Common reasons for Denied Workers’ Compensation Benefits claims include:

  • Injury not reported on time: There are usually strict deadlines for reporting a work injury, often ranging from just a few days to a month depending on your state. These deadlines are in place to ensure a timely investigation and to prevent fraudulent claims. If you fail to report the injury within the designated timeframe, it could be grounds for denial. This is because the insurance company may argue that the injury didn’t occur at work, or that the delay in reporting makes it difficult to investigate the claim properly.

Here’s why timely reporting is important:

  • Preserves evidence: The sooner an injury is reported, the easier it is to gather evidence like witness statements and video footage from security cameras.
  • Establishes a clear connection: Reporting the injury right away creates a clear connection between the incident and your injury. Delays can raise questions about when and how the injury actually happened.
  • Allows for prompt medical attention: Early medical attention is crucial for both your health and your claim. Reporting the injury allows your employer to direct you to authorized medical providers who can document your work-related injury.

If you experience a work injury, even if it seems minor at first, report it to your supervisor immediately. This will protect your rights and ensure a smoother claims process should you require medical attention or lost wages down the line.

  • Injury Not Work-Related: For a work injury to be eligible for Workers’ Compensation benefits, it must have arisen “in the course and scope” of your employment. This legal concept essentially means the injury happened while you were fulfilling your job duties and at a time and place connected to your work. Here’s a breakdown of what this entails:=
    • Time: The injury needs to occur within your designated work hours or during a work-authorized activity. For instance, if you’re injured while running a work errand during your lunch break, it might be covered. However, injuries sustained during your commute to and from work generally wouldn’t be eligible.
    • Place: The injury must happen at your workplace or somewhere you were required to be for work purposes. This could include worksites, business trips, or even attending company events outside the office. Injuries sustained at home, even if related to work tasks you’re doing remotely, typically fall outside the scope of coverage.
    • Duties: The injury should be directly related to the tasks you’re expected to perform for your job. This includes accidents that happen while using work equipment, performing assigned duties, or responding to work emergencies. Injuries sustained while engaging in personal activities unrelated to your work wouldn’t be covered.

There can be some gray areas, particularly concerning breaks or travel for work. If you’re unsure whether your specific situation qualifies as “in the course and scope” of employment, consulting with a Workers’ Compensation attorney is highly recommended. They can help you understand the specific laws in your state and determine the eligibility of your claim

  • Pre-existing Conditions: Pre-existing conditions can be a major hurdle in workers’ compensation claims. If you have a condition present before your work injury, the insurer might use it as a reason to:
    • Deny your entire claim: This often happens if the insurer argues the pre-existing condition was the sole cause of your current injury.
    • Accept a portion of the claim: In some cases, the insurer might acknowledge that your work injury aggravated a pre-existing condition. Here, they may only agree to cover the worsening of your symptoms, not the entire condition itself. This can get complicated, especially when proving the extent to which work contributed to your current situation.

What You Can Do:

  • Gather medical evidence: Having clear medical documentation that separates your pre-existing condition from the work-related injury is crucial. This could involve doctor’s reports outlining how the work incident specifically worsened your pre-existing condition.
  • Know your state laws: Workers’ compensation laws vary by state. Some states have specific rules for handling pre-existing condition cases. Understanding these laws can strengthen your position.
  • Consider legal counsel: An experienced workers’ compensation attorney can help you navigate the complexities of pre-existing conditions and fight for the full benefits you deserve. They can analyze your situation, gather appropriate evidence, and ensure your pre-existing condition doesn’t unfairly disadvantage your claim.


  • Lack of Medical Evidence:  Strong medical evidence directly linking your injury to the work incident is crucial for a successful Denied Workers’ Compensation Benefits claim. This evidence comes in two main forms:
    • Documentation of the initial injury: Seek medical attention as soon as possible after a work injury, even if the pain seems minor. A prompt medical evaluation establishes a clear timeline connecting the injury to the work event. The doctor will document your symptoms, conduct a physical examination, and potentially order diagnostic tests (like X-rays or MRIs) to confirm the injury’s nature and severity.
    • Ongoing medical care: Continuing medical treatment for your work injury strengthens your claim. Regular doctor visits document the progress of your treatment and any limitations you experience due to the injury. This ongoing record helps establish a clear connection between the work incident and your current medical condition.

Building a Strong Medical Case:

  • Be truthful and consistent: Provide accurate information about your injury and how it happened during all medical appointments. Inconsistency can raise doubts about the validity of your claim.
  • Follow your doctor’s orders: Attending all scheduled appointments, adhering to prescribed treatment plans, and completing recommended therapies demonstrate your commitment to recovery and bolster your claim’s credibility.
  • Obtain medical records: Request copies of all your medical records related to the work injury. Having these readily available will be crucial when appealing a Denied Workers’ Compensation Benefits claim.

By ensuring you have comprehensive medical documentation, you significantly strengthen your case and increase your chances of a successful appeal.


Steps to Take After a Denied Workers’ Compensation Benefits Claim

  • Review the denial letter carefully: This document is critical. It will explain the specific reason your Denied Workers’ Compensation Benefits claim was rejected. Common reasons for denial are listed above, but the exact details will be unique to your case. Read the letter thoroughly, taking note of any dates, deadlines, or reference codes mentioned. The denial letter should also outline the appeals process available to you in your state. This will typically involve specific steps you need to take and deadlines for filing an appeal. Don’t hesitate to highlight or underline important information in the letter for easy reference later.

In some cases, the denial letter may reference specific sections of workers’ compensation law or company policy used to justify the decision.  If you’re unfamiliar with these legal references, this is a good time to start gathering information. You can try researching the legal code online or consult with an attorney to understand the reasoning behind the denial.

  • Gather documentation: Compile a comprehensive file of everything that supports your Denied Workers’ Compensation Benefits claim. This should include any medical records related to the work injury, including doctor’s visit notes, diagnostic test results, and treatment plans. Witness statements from anyone who saw the accident or can verify the details of your injury can be valuable. Additionally, obtain a copy of the accident report filed by your employer or any police reports generated at the scene. The more documentation you have, the stronger your case will be when appealing the Denied Workers’ Compensation Benefits decision.
  • Contact your employer: While a denial can be discouraging, don’t underestimate the power of open communication. Reach out to your employer and request a meeting to discuss the denied Workers’ Compensation Benefits claim. Explain your situation and the reasoning behind the denial.  This conversation can be an opportunity to address any misunderstandings or missing information the employer may have.  For instance, perhaps there’s a crucial detail about the accident that wasn’t documented or the company has a modified duties program you weren’t aware of. By presenting your case directly and demonstrating your willingness to work towards a resolution, you might be surprised at the employer’s willingness to reconsider the denial.
  • Appeal the decision: Appealing a Denied Workers’ Compensation Benefits claim is crucial to securing the financial assistance you need.  Each state has a designated workers’ compensation commission that oversees the appeals process.  This typically involves filing a formal appeal request with the commission, outlining why you believe the initial decision was incorrect. Be sure to include any new evidence you may have gathered since the initial claim was denied.  Since deadlines for filing appeals are strict, it’s important to act quickly. Missing the deadline could significantly weaken your case or even eliminate your right to appeal altogether. Consider this your window of opportunity to fight for the compensation you deserve, so don’t delay in initiating the appeals process.
  • Consult with a Workers’ Compensation Attorney: Don’t underestimate the value of consulting with a Workers’ Compensation Attorney.  An attorney with experience in these cases can be a game-changer. They can guide you through the often complex appeals process, ensuring all deadlines are met and paperwork is filed correctly.  Furthermore, they will be adept at gathering evidence to strengthen your claim, such as acquiring medical records, witness testimonies, and potentially even consulting with medical experts.  Perhaps most importantly, an attorney can represent you at hearings, ensuring your voice is heard and your rights are protected throughout the entire process.


Don’t Give Up on Your Denied Workers’ Compensation Benefits Claim


While a denied Workers’ Compensation Benefits claim can be frustrating, it doesn’t mean you’re out of options. By following these steps – understanding the reason for the denial, gathering documentation, contacting your employer, and potentially appealing the decision – you can fight for the compensation you deserve. Remember, an experienced Workers’ Compensation Attorney can be a valuable asset in this process, helping you navigate the complexities of the appeal and advocating for your rights. The sooner you take action after a denial, the stronger your case will be and the quicker you can get the financial help you need to recover.

Here at RG Injury Law (, we understand the complexities of the Workers’ Compensation system in Pennsylvania. Our experienced attorneys have a proven track record of success in helping injured workers obtain the benefits they deserve. If you’ve been denied Workers’ Compensation benefits, we offer free consultations to discuss your case and explore your legal options. Don’t hesitate to contact us today to schedule a consultation and get the legal help you need.

  • Bill Gregory

    I fight to obtain the greatest recovery for my clients, but I pride myself on listening to my clients and being there for them through the fight.


RG Injury Law Resource Center

Workers Comp and Forced Resignationthumbnail-image-of-what-to-expect-during-your-workers-compensation-case-in-rg-injury-law